Skip to content
Code readers and scan tools are the two primary devices most car owners and mechanics turn to. Knowing the key differences will help you choose the right one based on your needs and budget. We’ll break down the key differences between code readers and scan tools, helping you make a well-informed decision.
What is a Code Reader
A car code reader is a basic automotive diagnostic tool used to retrieve Diagnostic Trouble Codes (DTCs) from a vehicle’s onboard diagnostic system (OBD). These codes indicate problems or malfunctions in various vehicle systems, primarily the engine and emissions systems.
Code readers are typically designed for ease of use, making them an excellent choice for DIY car owners or people who want a simple, no-frills tool for basic vehicle diagnostics.
How Does a Code Reader Work
The process of using a code reader is straightforward. Once connected to your vehicle’s OBD-II port (usually located under the dashboard), the device will scan the car’s systems and return codes that indicate issues. These codes can be looked up in a database or manual to identify the specific problem. Some code readers also allow you to clear or reset the trouble codes after the issue has been resolved.
Pros of Using a Code Reader
- Affordability: Code readers are typically less expensive than scan tools.
- Simplicity: They are easy to use with basic functionality, perfect for quick diagnostics.
- Compact Size: Most code readers are lightweight and portable.
- Speed: They quickly retrieve trouble codes with minimal setup.
Cons of Using a Code Reader
- Limited Functionality: Code readers only provide the trouble codes, not much more detailed information.
- Lack of Advanced Features: Code readers cannot perform in-depth diagnostics or offer real-time data.
- No Advanced System Access: They typically don't offer the ability to test specific components or check other systems like transmission, ABS, or airbags.
What is a Scan Tool
A auto scan tool is a more advanced diagnostic device that provides a deeper look into a vehicle’s systems. Scan tools not only retrieve the same trouble codes as code readers, but they also allow you to access more extensive vehicle data, including live data streams, freeze frame data, and sensor readings. These tools are ideal for professional mechanics or advanced DIYers who need a comprehensive understanding of vehicle performance.
Related Reading: Why Are Bidirectional Scan Tools So Expensive?
How Does a Scan Tool Work
Much like a code reader, a scan tool is plugged into the OBD-II port. However, scan tools are equipped with more sophisticated software and hardware, allowing them to not only read car trouble code but also monitor real-time data from various sensors, perform diagnostic tests, and even reset certain vehicle settings. This makes them a versatile choice for more complex diagnostics and repairs.
Pros of Using a Scan Tool
-
Advanced Features: Scan tools can retrieve more detailed information about your vehicle, including live data and freeze-frame data.
-
Broad System Coverage: They can scan a wider range of vehicle systems like transmission, airbags, ABS, and more.
-
Live Data Streaming: Scan tools allow you to monitor real-time performance data from your vehicle's sensors, helping you detect issues as they happen.
-
Enhanced Troubleshooting: They often include built-in diagnostics, allowing you to pinpoint the exact cause of a problem.
Cons of Using a Scan Tool
-
Cost: Scan tools are generally more expensive than code readers, especially advanced models.
-
Complexity: These tools have more functions and may require some learning to use effectively.
-
Size: Some scan tools are larger and less portable than code readers, though many models are still compact enough for everyday use.
Key Differences Between Code Readers and Scan Tools
Functionality
While both code readers and scan tools read DTCs, scan tools offer a far more comprehensive range of diagnostic functions. Scan tools can access data from numerous systems within the vehicle and provide real-time monitoring. They also allow you to perform advanced tests like ABS system tests, sensor calibration, and more, which code readers simply cannot do.
Price
Price is one of the most significant differentiators. Code readers are typically priced lower, making them a good choice for those looking for a budget-friendly solution. In contrast, scan tools can range from mid to high-end prices, with professional-grade models being much more expensive due to their additional capabilities.
Ease of Use
If you’re looking for simplicity, code readers are the way to go. They are designed to be easy with basic functionalities, perfect for individuals who need quick diagnostic results without getting into the weeds. Scan tools require a bit more technical know-how to maximize their potential, though they are not impossible for non-professionals to use.
Vehicle Compatibility
Most code readers will work with any vehicle that complies with OBD-II standards (which includes all vehicles manufactured after 1996 in the U.S.). However, scan tools often offer more vehicle specific capabilities, allowing access to features like transmission diagnostics, airbag systems, and more. Some high-end scan tools even support vehicles from multiple manufacturers, offering comprehensive coverage across various makes and models.
$439.99
Which One Should You Buy
Buy a Code Reader If…
-
You’re looking for a budget-friendly solution.
-
You only need to read and clear trouble codes.
-
You’re not concerned with advanced diagnostics or real-time data.
-
You want something simple for personal use and occasional troubleshooting.
Buy a Scan Tool If…
-
You need more detailed diagnostics across a variety of systems.
-
You want to monitor live data from your vehicle’s sensors.
-
You’re a professional mechanic or an advanced DIYer.
-
You need the ability to perform advanced tests or resets.
Conclusion
When deciding between a code reader and a scan tool, it’s essential to consider your needs and the level of diagnostic information you require. If you're a casual driver looking for a quick and inexpensive way to clear check engine lights and understand basic issues, a code reader will likely be sufficient. However, if you’re dealing with more complex vehicle problems or need in-depth data and testing, investing in a scan tool will be the better choice.
FAQs
Can a code reader perform live data streaming?
No, code readers do not provide live data streaming. Scan tools are the better option if you need to monitor real-time data from your vehicle’s sensors or perform ongoing diagnostics.
Is a code reader enough for a professional mechanic?
A code reader is generally not sufficient for professional mechanics, as it lacks the advanced diagnostic capabilities needed for complex vehicle problems. A scan tool is more suitable for professional use due to its broader range of features and system coverage.
What is the price difference between code readers and scan tools?
Code readers are generally more affordable, typically ranging from $20 to $100, making them a budget-friendly option. Scan tools, especially those with advanced features, can range from $100 to $500 or more, depending on their capabilities.
Recommended Similar Articles：
- Is Your Transmission Slipping? Here’s What Could Be Wrong and How to Fix It
- Coolant Leaks: Causes, Signs, and Solutions
- 10 Reasons Why Your Car Won’t Rev Past 4000 RPM [+Recommended Car Tools by Mechanics to Fix It]
- Where is the ECM Module Located in Chrysler
- How to Diagnose and Repair a Cooling Fan Motor Relay
